Armchair Cyentist | MLB Pitcher Rankings

Pitchers

385

Total Innings

9301.4

Games

4269

Avg ERA

4.44

Our Secret Stats Weapon: Performance Score

We rank pitchers using our proprietary awRPP metric because we're stubborn nerds who think we're smarter than everyone else. But we are going to show you our Performance Score, which is a 0-100 scale where higher is better. The best pitcher gets a 100, the worst gets a 0, and everyone else is scaled proportionally. The colored progress bars let you visualize the gap between pitchers at a glance. Trust us, these scores are better than any stat you've seen on TV.

Top 10 Pitchers

The Cream of the Crop

If these pitchers aren't on your Cy Young shortlist, you're holding your ballot upside down. They represent the most valuable arms in baseball and should be getting the biggest paychecks. GMs take note: these are the pitchers worth breaking the bank for.

#	Name	Team	Score	ERA	IP	G	Runs	Salary	Type	Role	Pitches
1	José Soriano	Los Angeles	100.0	1.75	46.2	8	9.0	$???	Mixed	Starter	752
2	Cam Schlittler	New York	99.6	1.91	47.1	8	10.0	$???	Groundball	Starter	694
3	Max Fried	New York	99.6	2.94	58.2	9	19.0	$14.5M	Groundball	Starter	856
4	Davis Martin	Chicago	99.6	1.64	44.0	7	8.0	$765.5K	Mixed	Starter	628
5	Clay Holmes	New York	99.3	1.71	42.2	7	8.0	$13M	Groundball	Starter	630
6	Chris Sale	Atlanta	99.3	2.39	49.0	8	13.0	$22M	Groundball	Starter	746
7	Justin Wrobleski	Los Angeles	99.2	1.25	36.0	6	5.0	$800K	Mixed	Starter	517
8	Parker Messick	Cleveland	99.2	2.3	47.0	8	12.0	$???	Mixed	Starter	716
9	Michael McGreevy	St. Louis	99.1	2.2	45.1	8	11.0	$???	Groundball	Starter	709
10	Nick Martinez	Tampa Bay	99.1	1.71	42.0	7	8.0	$21.1M	Groundball	Starter	588

All Qualified Pitchers

Qualification threshold: 10 innings pitched Loading pitchers...

Loading pitcher data...

Automatic Data Updates

Stats are automatically updated every 12 hours, because we're lazy and would otherwise forget to update it ourselves.

Last updated: May 10, 2026 at 07:19